Skip to content
← All posts Prototyping

FDM vs SLA vs CNC: which prototype process should you use?

Most prototype questions come down to three processes. Here is how we decide between them in our lab, with the prices and lead times we actually charge.

Sergio FloresFounder, Flores Engineering7 min read
Row of FDM 3D printers in the Flores Engineering lab in Kearny, NJ

Every week someone sends us a CAD file and asks the same thing: should this be printed or machined? The honest answer depends on what the part has to prove. A part that only needs to show size and shape has different needs than one that has to hold a screw, survive heat or look like the final product.

We run all three processes in our Kearny, NJ lab, so we have no reason to push one over another. This is the decision guide we use.

The short version

FDM 3D printingSLA resin printingCNC machining
Best forFunctional parts, fixtures, enclosuresFine detail, smooth surfaces, clear partsReal metal, tight tolerances, wear parts
Typical costFrom $0.25 per gramBy resin volume and print time$55 per machine hour + $45 setup
Lead time2 business days3 business days5 business days
Max size (in-house)256 × 256 × 256 mm200 × 125 × 210 mm360 × 240 × 140 mm
SurfaceVisible layer linesSmooth, near injection-moldedMachined finish
Minimum order$35$35$35

Choose FDM when the part has to work

FDM (fused deposition modeling) builds parts from melted plastic filament, one layer at a time. It is the cheapest and fastest way to get a part you can actually use: snap it onto a bracket, mount a board inside it, drop it on the floor.

  • Fit checks and early form studies
  • Fixtures, jigs and assembly aids for the shop floor
  • Enclosures and housings for electronics
  • Brackets and mounts that carry light loads

Material choice matters more than most people expect. PLA is fine for a fit check but softens in a hot car. PETG and ABS handle more heat and impact. Carbon-fiber nylon (PA6-CF) is stiff and strong enough for many end-use mechanical parts.

The trade-off is surface finish and accuracy. Layer lines show, and holes print slightly undersize. If a pin needs an exact fit, plan to ream or drill the hole after printing.

Choose SLA when it has to look right

SLA (stereolithography) cures liquid resin with a laser. Parts come out smooth and detailed, close to what a molded part looks like. That makes SLA the right choice for appearance models, small detailed parts and anything transparent.

  • Appearance prototypes for investor or retail demos
  • Small parts with fine features, text or thin walls
  • Clear parts: light pipes, windows, fluid views
  • Patterns for silicone molds and casting

Standard resins are more brittle than FDM plastics, so they are not ideal for snap fits or parts that take impact. Engineering resins like Tough 2000 and Rigid 10K close much of that gap, at a higher material cost.

Choose CNC when it has to be real

CNC machining cuts the part from a solid block. You get the real material, aluminum, brass or Delrin, with real mechanical properties and tighter tolerances than printing can hold.

  • Aluminum brackets, plates and small housings
  • Parts that see heat, load or wear
  • Bushings, slides and gears in Delrin
  • Final validation parts that must match production material

Machining costs more per part and takes longer, mostly because of setup time and toolpath programming. It also has geometry limits: inside corners need a radius, and deep narrow pockets get expensive fast.

A simple rule of thumb

Ask what the prototype has to prove. If it proves fit and function, print it in FDM. If it proves appearance or fine detail, print it in SLA. If it proves strength, heat resistance or production-grade accuracy, machine it.

Most of our product development projects use all three at different stages. Early proof-of-concept builds are almost always FDM. Design-review models for founders and investors are often SLA. Engineering validation units mix printed housings with machined metal parts where loads are highest.

Design tips that save a reprint

  • FDM: keep walls at least 1.2 mm thick and leave 0.2 mm clearance between mating parts.
  • SLA: keep walls at least 0.6 mm and add drain holes to hollow parts.
  • CNC: send a STEP file, not an STL, and add a drawing for tolerances tighter than ±0.1 mm or for threads.

Not sure which one fits? Pick "Not sure" when you upload your files and an engineer will recommend a process before anything is made.

Have a part in mind?

Upload your files and an engineer will confirm the best process and price.
Get a part quote

More from the blog

Resin 3D printer in the Flores Engineering labManufacturing · 5 min read

How to get a 3D printed part quoted fast (and what files to send)

What to include when you ask for a 3D printing or CNC quote: file formats, units, quantity, material and deadlines. A checklist from our NJ prototype lab.

Injection-molded consumer product shown in six colorwaysEngineering · 8 min read

10 design rules for injection-molded parts

Ten design for manufacturing (DFM) rules for injection-molded plastic parts: wall thickness, draft, ribs, bosses, radii and undercuts. From our product engineering team.